Week 6 Writing Homework
- November 20, 2024
- 7:25 pm
- 49 Comments
Writing Homework :
Topic: Should Three Mile Island be transformed into a fusion power facility?
Prompt: Should the historic site of Three Mile Island, known for its infamous nuclear accident, be repurposed into a fusion power facility? Argue for or against this transformation, considering the legacy of nuclear power, the promise of fusion technology, and the lessons from past accidents. Use evidence from Rick’s perspective as both the grandson of a fission accident survivor and the son of a fusion pioneer to support your position.
Interview Questions:
1. What extracurricular activities are you involved in?
2. Can you describe a personal achievement you’re particularly proud of?
3. Why are you interested in attending our school? What are your long-term academic and career goals?
4. Why do you deserve this scholarship?
Submit your homework as comment below:
Please upload your homework as a comment below:
49 thoughts on “Week 6 Writing Homework”
this is my writing, yay. \
P.S. I wrote it as a letter
WK6 Persuaive letter fusion power facility
FEEDBACK
Cherie- FEEDBACK
A Second Chance for Three Mile Island
The cooling tower stood tall and defiant, its colossal frame dominating the landscape. Rick stood in front of the imperial monolith, staring at the giant. The new glint of its pristine surface glowed as Rick admired its sheer size and structure spoke of a bygone era of confidence and ambition. To Rick, the tower was more than a relic; it was a symbol of both humanity’s audacity and its capacity for error. He ran his hand along the cold, weathered concrete, feeling its history seep into his fingertips. A surge of determination rose within him—this place, scarred yet enduring, deserved a second chance.
Rick’s father had spent his life chasing the elusive dream of fusion energy. He had poured his heart and resources into a prototype reactor that failed just short of success, leaving his name tied to what many called an impossible pursuit. After the experiment commenced, a huge explosion claimed many lives as the nuclei unexpectedly malfunctioned. Rick had grown up watching his father grapple with disappointment, hearing him insist that fusion was the future—a clean, limitless power that would redeem the sins of fission. After his father’s death, Rick couldn’t let that dream die. He’d rebuilt the prototype, fine-tuned the designs, and vowed to prove the world wrong. Today, his father’s vision would either rise from the ashes or fall forever silent.
Rick stood there, watching the tower that was soon to be activated. The distant hum of generators buzzed with anticipation as if preparing for this moment. Inside, Rick wrestled with his thoughts, his stomach twisting into knots. Was he truly ready for this? The weight of legacy pressed on him like a physical force, his father’s voice echoing in his mind: “Failure is just a step toward progress.” But what if this step led to a fall too steep to recover from?
As the sun rose higher, painting the sky in shades of gold, Rick’s mind churned with doubts. Had he checked every system? Was the reactor stable? Could the site, haunted by the ghosts of its past, ever truly shed its reputation? And what of the people watching him, expecting a miracle? He feared their disappointment more than his own failure. The tower loomed in the distance, a silent witness to his turmoil. What if I’m wrong? he thought. What if this is another disaster waiting to happen?
The cold wind whipping against his face as the sea crashed violently against the jagged rocks below. His hand hovered just above the keypad, fingers trembling with the weight of a decision he couldn’t take back. The lever beyond that steel door would bring life to the island—light, heat, and hope for the weary souls relying on him. But the cost clawed at the back of his mind: the haunting specter of what could go wrong. A meltdown, a failure, even a single misstep could turn this haven into a wasteland. His breath came shallow and ragged, misting in the icy air as he stared at the panel, each beep of the countdown timer in his mind growing louder.
He clenched his fists, trying to still the tremor in his hands, but the ache in his chest only grew heavier. The distant cries of seagulls sounded like warnings, the relentless waves below like accusations. Sweat trickled down his temple despite the chill, and he closed his eyes for a moment, searching for clarity in the storm inside his head. The lever loomed large in his imagination, its promise both salvation and potential ruin. Opening his eyes again, Rick exhaled sharply, forcing himself to focus. He had to decide—now—before doubt swallowed him whole. The crowd gathered, murmurs of anticipation filling the air as Rick stepped onto the platform. His heart pounded in his chest as his hand hovered over the red activation button.
He took a deep breath, glancing one last time at the fusion reactor he had spent so long perfecting. Finally, he pressed the button. A low hum began to build, the reactor’s inner mechanisms springing to life. Within seconds, a brilliant blue glow emanated from the core as the process of combining atomic nuclei for energy unfolded. Lights flickered, then steadied, and the tower, once dormant, crackled with renewed energy. The crowd erupted into cheers as the lights across the site illuminated, one by one, like stars coming alive in the night.
FEEDBACK
tli.sydney- FEEDBACK
Week 6 Scholarly Writing
Should the historic site of Three Mile Island, known for its infamous nuclear accident, be repurposed into a fusion power facility? Argue for or against this transformation, considering the legacy of nuclear power, the promise of fusion technology, and the lessons from past accidents. Use evidence from Rick’s perspective as both the grandson of a fission accident survivor and the son of a fusion pioneer to support your position.
NUCLEAR FUSION, the deadly weapon of the future. Today, I am standing on the very island where it happened. Three Mile Island. It experienced the most severe nuclear accident in the United States, yet people are now trying to bring it back. In this meeting, Dr Sarah Thompson has proposed a plan to restart the Three Mile Island Nuclear Plant, to begin what not only seems like, but is foreshadowing the impending doom of a horrific accident ahead. In the speech I will give you two reasons and a counter argument on why we should halt this proposal, due to public health hazards, radioactive waste disposal and the reality of its effect on the environment.
First of all, the nuclear power plant would be a public health hazard. The reason Three Mile Island has so much fame is because of the worst nuclear accident that happened in the US. Although it wasn’t as serious as Ukraine’s Cherobyl accident, it still poses a threat to the public’s health. It may not have contaminated air, but the redemption of the nuclear plant would be extremely risky. A single mistake would erase ourselves from existence. It is simply too dangerous and inconsiderate for people to resurrect the reason why Three Mile Island can be considered unsafe. The community should not be exposed to such rash risks for innovation of technology. Hence a nuclear power plant would pose a threat to the local community.
In addition, it is difficult to responsibly dispose of radioactive waste. Unfortunately, not only do nuclear power plants have a public health risk, it produces radioactive waste as a by-product, like uranium contaminated millings. This is very hard to dispose of, and if we don’t dispose of it, it will build up and once again pose another threat to the environment and the public. There are no current ways to dispose of it responsibly, and because of this, many countries like Japan are dumping their radioactive waste into the ocean, which is bound to cause many environmental issues. We need to be more responsible and sustainable, therefore without nuclear power plants, there is much less radioactive waste that is difficult to dispose of. Hence, nuclear power plants produce radioactive waste with challenging disposal.
Furthermore, there are many counter-arguments I would like to present to you. I acknowledge that yes, creating a nuclear power plant creates little to none greenhouse gases, which is why some environmentalists look at it as a possible solution as a renewable energy source. In fact, it is NOT considered renewable energy in many ways. As mentioned in the paragraph above, nuclear fusion creates radioactive waste that harms the environment, and since it is difficult to dispose of, it can bring a long lasting effect on the environment. Also, nuclear power plants need a water source nearby to cool the plant. There is a depleting number of countries in the world that have sufficient water and are not in danger of droughts. As climate change drinks up the earth’s freshwater sources, nuclear plants are simply accelerating the depletion of our natural resources, which is therefore, NOT sustainable at all. I also acknowledge that it may produce a higher power output than solar panels and wind farms, but its tremendous negative impact on the environment simply outweighs the slim benefits of nuclear fusion as a power source.
Ultimately, nuclear fusion is not the way of the future. Although it produces near to none greenhouse gases and has a higher power output, its impacts on the environment and also the public prove it to be an unsuitable and unsustainable way of creating energy. Thank you.
FEEDBACK
B H- FEEDBACK
Rick walked around the cold cracked outskirts of the building. He gazed at the seemingly ancient buildings imagining the past, when it released a fury of white cloudy smoke. The place was a tragedy, killing 500 people working there, and was considered a bad omen. However, Rick looked past those beliefs and knew that this restricted zone deserved a second chance, but would anyone even care?
His father always thought that nuclear fusion was the key to all locks, and even built a whole prototype on a nuclear power plant. However, there was a reaction failure which claimed many lives including his father’s. He was tempted to believe what everyone had said and not see all the colour in the possibility. But he couldn’t just let the dream go. So, he rebuilt the prototype, refining the errors and making sure that every centimetre was correct.
Today was the day, to either relive another nightmare, or rescue the dream from all ashes. He stood there gazing at the powerplant. Failure is just an obstacle, just break through it. Then he thought what if this time it was too thick.
He moved into the control room, pondering questions. Had I checked everything. Was this going to be another failure? He looked at the key of the control room breathing slowly. He looked at the room staring at the big red button in the centre of the panel and this could either be good or bad.
His hand hovered over the button wishing it would work. What would people say if it didn’t work again? He breathed, his hand pressed the button. The reactor hummed as he stored it in the building. Lights flickered and completely shut down. Groans were heard and as all hope was lost, the light burst open, revealing a promising future, and his dad’s dream.
FEEDBACK
grace.creek- FEEDBACK
Writing Homework :
Topic: Should Three Mile Island be transformed into a fusion power facility?
Prompt: Should the historic site of Three Mile Island, known for its infamous nuclear accident, be repurposed into a fusion power facility? Argue for or against this transformation, considering the legacy of nuclear power, the promise of fusion technology, and the lessons from past accidents. Use evidence from Rick’s perspective as both the grandson of a fission accident survivor and the son of a fusion pioneer to support your position.
Interview Questions:
1. What extracurricular activities are you involved in?
2. Can you describe a personal achievement you’re particularly proud of?
3. Why are you interested in attending our school?
4. What are your long-term academic and career goals?
5. Why do you deserve this scholarship?
WRITING HOMEWORK SUBMISSION:
Should the historic site of Three Mile Island, known for its infamous nuclear accident, be repurposed into a fusion power facility? There have been many arguments for this topic and many different perspectives. Today I am going to share my perspective.
Imagine this, a horrific accident. Many health hazards everywhere, spreading around the globe. The local community scared, for what feels like forever. This is what happened in 1979. After the accident, there are still many problems. No one would want that horrific and terrifying accident to happen again. Except, it could. People are arguing that the Three Mile Island, the place where the problems all began, should be turned into a fusion power facility. If that happens problems would start. All because everyone knows that history can repeat itself.
First of all, there are many reasons why the change shouldn’t happen. Here are some examples. The nuclear power plant would be a public health hazard. It can cause serious illnesses and can cause many hazards. The reason Three Mile Island has so much fame is because of the worst nuclear accident that happened in the US. Although it wasn’t as serious as Ukraine’s Chernobyl accident, it still poses a threat to the public’s health. This is just one reason why bringing back this dangerous plant could be a threat to all life on earth. A single mistake would erase ourselves from existence. It is too risky to try and bring back what could barely, just barely be stopped. One problem could lead to catastrophic events.
Another reason why we shouldn’t go through with these changes is that the last accident at the Three Mile Island had negligible effects on the physical health of individuals or the environment. The local community was traumatized by what happened and people are worried that it would happen again. That wasn’t the only big problem there was with this topic. Another nuclear accident happened in 1986. You may know it as it was The Chernobyl disaster which began on 26 April 1986 with the explosion of the No. 4 reactor of the Chernobyl Nuclear Power Plant. The explosion was enormous and had terrible effects. After these types of explosions, there is waste from the source left over. Which makes it even more terrifying as the waste is radioactive and is VERY harmful. That is another reason why the Three Mile Islan shouldn’t be turned into a fusion power facility.
Even though there are a few reasons why it can be a good thing, there are many more reasons why it isn’t. So next time this topic comes up, remember these reasons. If you can’t then just remember one thing. History can repeat itself.
INTERVIEW QUESTIONS:
1. I am involved in many extracurricular activities. Some of them include soccer, touch football, netball, tennis and dance. Except for most of these sports are only for one term as it is for IPSHA and school. I do them for Saturday Sports. The ones that I do all the time are dance (which I do hip – hop) soccer and tennis. I manly focus on soccer as it is my main sport and my favourite. I do soccer about 4 times a week, tennis once a week and dance once a week as well. Like I mentioned earlier, I also do other sports for 1 term each year as it is part of my school program, and you can choose to participate in the sports for the term or not. I always do a Saturday Sport each term as I love sport, and I would take as many opportunities as possible to do sports.
2. A personal achievement I am particularly proud of is when I made it into an ESFA team for soccer. I made it to the Under 11’s team and I am really happy and proud. I was so excited because we had to try out for it over 2 weekends for 2 trials. My mum was also really proud, and my dad because I made it into the team only after the first trial. I get to work and play with new people, and I get to do more soccer and play in more competitions. That is an achievement I am proud of.
3. My chosen school is the one I already go to, Ascham. I would love to get into the school because I’ve made some great friends, and I know many teachers. That’s not the only reason though. The sports programs are really good and there are many extracurriculars we can do. We get to participate in IPSHA sports, and I also started learning many new instruments at Ascham as well. I would love to be able to stay at Ascham as I love the experience there already and I would love to get a scholarship for Ascham.
4. There are many career opportunities and goals that I have and some of those include being a soccer player on the Matildas Girls Aussie Soccer Team. Except I know that’s really hard. That’s why another career goal is to be a fashion designer or an interior designer for houses. If those goals don’t go as planned, I also have my own business already. It’s called designs by Belle, and I have already sold many things. I sell keychains, bracelets and photo frames. I do Christmas themed things as well at Christmas time and when I’m an adult I could make my business even bigger. For my long – term academics goal, I’m not so sure that’s why I would like to learn many new things and get very good grades so in university, I can decide what I want to be when I’m older and start my path towards success.
5. I think I deserve this scholarship because I know this is the same for everyone, but I’ve tried really hard for a scholarship and I would be so appreciative to get one. I am a smart girl, and I am an all rounder as I have accomplished many achievements for sports and academics. Like for example, I got the end of term award last year for year 4, I was 1 out of 6 people to get an award in my category. For sports I have made it into an ESFA soccer team for Under 11’s and have gotten into the top team for soccer and touch football and the second highest team for netball and tennis. I have accomplished so much and have tried my absolute hardest to try and get scholarships as I also want to make my parents proud.
FEEDBACK
Annabelle Tung- FEEDBACK
Week 6 Writing Homework
Should We Replace 3 Mile Beach with a Fusion Power Facility
‘Should we eradicate our endearing 3 Mile Beach to forge a colossal, glistening Fusion Power Facility,’ Rick queried to the inquisitive crowd. ‘There are many advantages and imperilments to both sides of the decision. The Fusion Power Facility could benefit humanity. On the other hand, demolishing our cherished 3 Mile Beach is a vigorous thing to do, as if the 3 Mile Beach withers, so will our cherished memories in 3 Mile Beach,’ declared Rick. The question echoed throughout the town and laid on everyone’s shoulders. Their minds were pondering about their decision. What would be the fate of the 3 Mile Beach?
‘It is time for us to ascertain what the benefits of replacing 3 Mile Beach with a Fusion Power Facility. Fusion Power Facilities do not emanate CO2 or radioactive waste but instead it emits helium. These factories are among the enviroment friendly ones. Another sublime thing about a Fusion Power Facility is that it is almost four million times more energy than smouldering oil or coal, revealing its efficiency. Fusion Power does not have to rely on environmental activity like solar energy to operate,’ explains Rick. The crowd marvelled at Rick’s stupendous explanation.
‘Even though all of these statements sounds staggering, Fusion Power facilities have had numerous fatal accidents,’ announced Rick. Suddenly, tears, engulfed by melancholy cascaded down Rick’s crimson cheeks. ‘An example of this is when my mom, Sarah Thompson was involved in one of these loathed flukes,’ Rick divulged. Gasps spread around the elephantine stage rapidly. ‘The reason why Fusion Power Facilities are not used nowadays is because of the frequent and likelihood of accidents occurring. Furthermore, another reason we should not be exchanging this with the 3 Mile Beach is because nature in our life is fleeting. We keep on destroying poor nature to invent new structures in their places. One day, nature might be forgotten forever, unless we start to give it the respect it deserves,’ convinces Rick. The crowd deafeningly cheered.
Posters materialised against Fusion Power Facilities. Rick was a hero for 3 Mile Beach. An ecstatic grin stretched across Rick’s face. He had fulfilled his quest sent to him by his mom. The stars gleamed at Rick. Inside of Rick’s mind, emerged the moment when his mom was dying from the fusion accident. Her last words were lustier than the crowd.’ Son, remember to always choose nature over artificial. I know that you are the one to create an exquisite equilibrium I this world.’ Those words meant everything to Rick.
FEEDBACK
Bhupender _- FEEDBACK
week 6 wring homework
The Three Mile Island Nuclear Station Must Be Reopened as a Nuclear Fusion Power Site
FEEDBACK
ran.d.f.chen- FEEDBACK
Rick had always been proud of his family’s history. His grandfather, a calm and wise man, had lived through the chaotic days of the Three Mile Island Nuclear Power Accident. Learning about the disaster used to send chills down Rick’s spine. The stories his grandfather told painted a vivid picture of fear and uncertainty, a time when the world felt like it was teetering on the edge of disaster. Rick’s mother was a nuclear fusion pioneer, always dreaming of a cleaner, safer future. Despite her groundbreaking research, the talk of reviving Three Mile Island as a nuclear facility made Rick’s heart race with anxiety.
He remembered sitting at the family dinner table when the debate first heated up. “Why would anyone want to go back to something so dangerous?” he thought, frustration bubbling inside him. To Rick, the thought of turning Three Mile Island into a nuclear power plant again seemed like a terrible idea. For him, it was more than just an argument; it was personal.
Rick had heard plenty of arguments in favor of nuclear power. Proponents often spoke of clean energy and reducing carbon footprints, but they never seemed to mention the possibility of catastrophic failures. It was easy to forget the chaos that could ensue when a reactor malfunctioned. His grandfather would always remind him that while technology could advance, human error was a constant. The accident at Three Mile Island had changed their lives forever, and Rick believed the risk was simply too great to be taken lightly.
He imagined what could happen if another accident occurred. The memories of panicked evacuations, contaminated water, and the fear that wrapped around his community like a thick fog came rushing back. “Is the potential energy worth the lives it could disrupt?” he pondered quietly. The mention of “safety protocols” felt hollow when he considered the real human lives involved.
Rick knew that some people looked at nuclear power as a necessary step towards innovation. But he felt that there were better alternatives out there, like solar or wind energy, that didn’t come with the baggage of nuclear disasters. Why not invest in these safer options and leave the memories of Three Mile Island behind, where they belonged?
He thought about the future and the kind of world he wanted to live in. A world where energy doesn’t threaten his loved ones or his environment. Rick wanted to see more discussions focused on safer, innovative solutions rather than reopening old wounds. “Three Mile Island should stay closed for good,” he decided. The ghosts of the past were too vivid to ignore. In Rick’s eyes, embracing the future meant learning from the mistakes of the past, not repeating them.
FEEDBACK
Mei Li- FEEDBACK
The colossal pillar stood cool and defiant towering over the workers below. The cracked stone concrete and rusted metal bars lying in the junkyard stood as a testament to the infamous 1979 Three Mile Island incident. Rick stood in front of the imperial monolith, staring at the massive giant. The glint of the rusted but working stone towers that reached into the sky glowed as Rick stood in awe seeing its sheer size and structure. The towers were once the centre of energy supplying every inch of America, now spoke of a bygone era of confidence and ambition.
To Rick, the tower was more than a stone relic; it was a symbol of both humanity’s audacity and its capacity for error. He ran his hand along the cold, weathered concrete, feeling its history and importance seep into his delicate fingertips. A surge of determination rose within him—this place, scarred yet enduring, deserved a second chance.
Rick’s father had spent every second of his life grinding away at this monster of a power plant, sharing the same difficulties as his ordinary workers. He had poured his heart and resources into a prototype reactor that failed just short of success, leaving his name tied to what many called an impossible pursuit. That night the Unit 2 reactor had a meltdown and a few seconds later, the worst nuclear calamity happened right there at Three Mile Island. Rick’s father himself took the blame, the weight of melancholy and frustration pilling up on his shoulders.
The incident left him a broken man. Hated by thousands and sued by hundreds of people. The nuclear power plant, once the centre of America’s power industry, now lay in defeat, its towers once touching the stars, now lay crumbled on the floor. Three Mile Island, once a lively work place now lay in radioactive ruins abandoned and devoid of life.
Rick knew that he had to bring the dead back to life again. Even though his father’s countless warnings, he decided to go for it head on. Determination surged through his body like a flood, washing away all his other thoughts. He was build nuclear power plant back to its former glory days. Again, It would be the centre of America. he just needed to make that simple thought go into fruition.
The next day, construction workers arrived at the site. Many had already heard about the infamous accident but after hearing the urge and ambition in his speech, and seeing the fire, the urge, the desire to rebuild this place, they were as motivated as he was.
For the next few weeks, Rick and his team rebuilt the run down power plant brick by brick. Rick often pitched in and worked as hard as his workers, making them assured that he wasn’t cheating with the job. In a month, the first tower lumber back up. The next few popped up like the latest trend. Soon the plant was up and running.
The only difference was that, instead of nuclear energy, they would use a more sustainable, and safe option. Rick invited him to see the masterpiece they had built from rubble. His dad’s jaw touch the ground and his eyes opened wide in shock. He could barely hold his excitement in.
The nuclear power plant was once the centre of the wealthiest nation on Earth before falling down into rubble and being devoid of life, abandoned and inhospitable. Now, the plant had regained its former glory, rising up from the dead to become the centre of America’s power industry once again. After all the work, Rick sat down on a rock and looked up with accomplishment and inspiration at the stone towers rising into the sea of blue like a skyscraper, scraping the limits and the edge of the world. He had done it.
FEEDBACK
Eric Xu- FEEDBACK
Should Three Mile Island be transformed into a fusion power facility?
Three Mile Island is a site that many people associate with the dangers of nuclear energy. In 1979, the plant experienced a partial meltdown, which was a major accident in the history of nuclear power. However, looking at the site today, we have an opportunity to use it for something new and potentially much safer: fusion energy.
Fusion power could be the key to solving many of the world’s energy problems. Unlike fission, which is the technology used in nuclear reactors like the one at Three Mile Island, fusion does not create long-lasting radioactive waste or pose the same level of risk. Fusion works by combining hydrogen atoms to create energy, similar to what powers the sun. This process produces a lot of energy without the dangerous by-products of fission.
As someone whose grandfather survived a fission accident at a nuclear power plant, I understand the fear that nuclear power can cause. The memories of Three Mile Island and other accidents like Chernobyl are still fresh for many people. However, the lessons learned from these accidents have led to improved safety standards and technology in modern nuclear plants. While fission still carries risks, fusion is much safer. It cannot cause a runaway reaction like fission, and if something goes wrong, the reaction simply stops.
My father, a fusion pioneer, worked on developing fusion technology for decades. He often said that fusion could provide a nearly unlimited supply of clean energy without the harmful effects of traditional nuclear fission. The technology is still in the experimental stages, but there have been big breakthroughs in recent years. In fact, there have been successful fusion reactions that produced more energy than was needed to start the reaction. This shows that fusion could become a reliable and clean energy source in the near future.
Transforming Three Mile Island into a fusion power facility could not only help us solve our energy needs but also allow us to turn a symbol of nuclear disaster into a symbol of hope for the future. It would be a place where we learn from the mistakes of the past and build a better, safer energy future. Instead of leaving the site as a reminder of the dangers of fission, we could use it as a launching pad for the next generation of clean energy.
In conclusion, repurposing Three Mile Island for fusion energy makes sense. It would be a way to honor the lessons learned from past accidents, while also embracing the promise of a cleaner, safer future. Fusion power has the potential to change the world, and Three Mile Island could play a key role in that transformation.
FEEDBACK
yuezhu-xuehotmail-com- FEEDBACK
Should the historic site of Three Mile Island, known for its infamous nuclear accident, be repurposed into a fusion power facility? The site, historically known for the 1979 nuclear accident, offers a unique opportunity to move past the fears surrounding nuclear energy and embrace a cleaner, safer energy solution. As the survivor of a nuclear accident and the son of a fusion energy scientist, I’ve seen the dangers and potential of nuclear power. Fusion, in particular, represents a much safer, cleaner, and more sustainable energy option. By transforming Three Mile Island into a fusion power facility, we can turn a symbol of past mistakes into a beacon for the future.
Firstly, the accident at Three Mile Island significantly damaged public trust in nuclear power. While no one was seriously harmed, it triggered widespread fear, halting the growth of nuclear energy in the United States. My grandfather, a survivor of another nuclear accident, lived with the effects for the rest of his life. This personal connection has taught me the importance of nuclear safety. However, fusion power is a completely different technology. Unlike fission, which splits atoms and creates dangerous radioactive waste, fusion combines atoms to release energy, a process that occurs naturally in stars. Fusion produces far less waste, and the waste it does create is far less harmful. The fuel for fusion is abundant and can be extracted from seawater, making it a cleaner and more sustainable energy source.
Furthermore, repurposing Three Mile Island for fusion energy would allow us to move beyond the mistakes of the past and embrace a new, safer energy technology. Fusion power doesn’t just reduce environmental risks; it also holds the potential to solve the world’s growing energy needs. Currently, the world depends on fossil fuels like coal and oil, which contribute to climate change and pollution. Fusion energy, on the other hand, provides an almost limitless source of clean power. By transforming Three Mile Island into a fusion facility, we would not only be addressing our energy needs but also demonstrating that we have learned from past nuclear disasters.
In addition, fusion energy is closer to becoming a practical solution than many people realise. Over the last few years, there have been significant breakthroughs in fusion technology. Projects like ITER (International Thermonuclear Experimental Reactor) have shown that it is possible to generate more energy from fusion reactions than it takes to initiate them. Fusion power is still in the experimental phase, but scientists are optimistic that, within a few decades, fusion will become a reliable and commercially viable energy source. Repurposing Three Mile Island for fusion research would make the U.S. a leader in this promising field and accelerate the development of this clean energy solution.
Moreover, safety remains a top priority. While fusion is far safer than fission, we must approach its development with caution. The lessons learned from Three Mile Island should not be forgotten. If we move forward with fusion, we must ensure rigorous safety measures, transparency, and community involvement to rebuild trust. However, by repurposing the site of a past nuclear disaster into a cutting-edge fusion research facility, we would show that we can innovate safely and responsibly. This would help reassure the public that fusion power is a viable and safe option for the future.
In conclusion, transforming Three Mile Island into a fusion power facility would be a powerful symbol of progress. First of all, it would allow us to move past the mistakes of the past and embrace a safer, cleaner energy future. Fusion power offers an environmentally friendly solution to our global energy needs, and by repurposing this historic site, we would signal that the future of nuclear energy is bright. With fusion technology advancing rapidly, turning Three Mile Island into a research hub would help accelerate the shift to sustainable energy. Let’s take this opportunity to lead the world in safe, clean, and innovative energy solutions. Time for action starts now!
FEEDBACK
Gina- FEEDBACK
Rick’s hands flew across the control panel, where once his grandfather had once used to stop the calamity that had occurred that day. “This time it’s different.” Insisted his mother, Dr Sarah Thompson. “It’s fusion not fission, colliding the atoms not splitting. We’ve mastered it.” His grandfather shook his head “It was the same situation as before.”
Rick watched as his mother demonstrated the frosted anti-failure cooling system. “Fusion can’t have a meltdown. Physics itself prevents it.” “Back in 1979,” murmured his grandfather. “We were moments away from catastrophe. Now your mother says it’s perfectly safe. I want to believe her, but this place just holds too much unwanted memories.”
The research team collected soil samples and extracts plant DNA, the Universal Hyper Quantum computer showing 45 years of recovery since the accident. “Your mother could be right, preventing thousands of tons of carbon emissions.” Admitted his grandfather “But back then, during my time, we thought so too.”
The power plant stood there, looking grave, a crossroad of 30 billion dollars wasted or a quickly advancing economy. It seemed like even the slightest mis calculation could send it down the wrong path. Sensing his father’s doubtfulness, Dr Sarah Thompson quickly said, “This time we have physics to prove it.”
The descending sun cast a warm glow over the cooling towers as a voice interrupted. “Perhaps, the best way to remember the past is to improving it.”
Rick’s hands flew across the control panel, where once his grandfather had once used to stop the calamity that had occurred that day. “This time it’s different.” Insisted his mother, Dr Sarah Thompson. “It’s fusion not fission, colliding the atoms not splitting. We’ve mastered it.” His grandfather shook his head “It was the same situation as before.”
Rick watched as his mother demonstrated the frosty anti-failure cooling system. “Fusion can’t have a meltdown. Physics itself prevents it.” “Back in 1979,” murmured his grandfather. “We were moments away from catastrophe. Now your mother says it’s perfectly safe. I want to believe her, but this place just holds too much unwanted memories.”
The research team collected soil samples and extracts plant DNA, the Universal Hyper Quantum computer showing 45 years of recovery since the accident. “Your mother could be right, preventing thousands of tons of carbon emissions.” Admitted his grandfather “But back then, during my time, we thought so too.”
The power plant stood there, looking grave, a crossroad of 30 billion dollars wasted or a quickly advancing economy. It seemed like even the slightest mis calculation could send it down the wrong path. Sensing his father’s doubtfulness, Dr Sarah Thompson quickly said, “This time we have physics to prove it.”
The descending sun cast a warm glow over the cooling towers as a voice interrupted. “Perhaps, the best way to remember the past is to improving it.”
FEEDBACK
Tony Jian – FEEDBACK
Interview Questions:
1. What extracurricular activities are you involved in?
2. Can you describe a personal achievement you’re particularly proud of?
3. Why are you interested in attending our school? What are your long-term academic and career goals?
4. Why do you deserve this scholarship?
1.The extracurricular activities I’m involved in are Gala days where you play for 3 rounds. and each play 3 to 4 games in one round. Other activities I’m involved in is state knockout and math Olympiad. In state knockout we made it to round two but narrowly lost 2:0 against Wilton. Math Olympiad was a great extracurricular activity because it boosted my mind to grow more because of the brain puzzling questions and I really thrived in that environment of learning.
2.A personal achievement I’m very proud of was in 2023 where I had a very successful campaign in the cross country sector because of the fabulous results I accumulated in the process. The result I am most proud is at state where I came 26 out of 78. Which is a massive achievement and to go with all that I got awarded with Best sports boy of the year for 2023.
3.The reason I am interested in attending your school is because there are a lot of opportunities of growth and extracurricular activities to participate in and I can thrive in challenged environments. My long-term academic goals are to study a degree in sports science which matched my passion for soccer and various other sports. My career goal is to become a soccer player because I have a tremendous passion for soccer. I would like to balance my academics with my passion for soccer.
4.I deserve this scholarship because I have a very uplifting nature, and I always motivates fellow peers. I never give up whatever and always push to my limits like in sports games and so much more. I always persevere through challenges. This is why I deserve this scholarship.
Interview Questions_
sorry, am i late in handing this in?
Writing
FEEDBACK
Ethan Lee- FEEDBACK
Should Three Mile Island Be Transformed into a Fusion Power Facility?
The transformation of the historic Three Mile Island (TMI) site into a fusion power facility is an intriguing proposition, but it requires careful consideration of the legacy of nuclear power, the promise of fusion technology, and the lessons we’ve learned from past accidents. As Rick, a person deeply connected to both the painful history of fission accidents and the hopeful future of fusion energy, I stand in favor of repurposing Three Mile Island into a fusion power facility. However, my perspective is shaped by a nuanced understanding of both the potential and the risks involved.
Three Mile Island, which witnessed the infamous 1979 partial meltdown, remains a symbol of the risks of nuclear fission. The accident profoundly impacted public trust in nuclear energy, leading to tighter regulations and a slowdown in the development of nuclear power in the United States. For my grandfather, a survivor of a fission accident, and for the countless others affected by nuclear incidents, the TMI accident represents a stark reminder of the potential dangers of fission technology. Yet, it also stands as a testament to the resilience of both the industry and the community in moving past such disasters.
The promise of fusion, on the other hand, offers a safer, cleaner future. Fusion power, the same process that powers the sun, produces energy without the long-lived radioactive waste of fission and carries a much lower risk of catastrophic failure. As the son of a fusion pioneer, I have witnessed the rapid advancements in fusion research and development. Companies around the world are making strides toward achieving net-positive fusion energy—sustaining a fusion reaction that generates more energy than it consumes. This technological leap holds the potential to provide clean, virtually limitless energy for future generations.
Repurposing the TMI site into a fusion power facility would be symbolic. It would transform a location once synonymous with nuclear fear into one that embodies a hopeful vision for sustainable energy. While there will inevitably be challenges in transitioning from fission to fusion, including regulatory hurdles and technological development, this transformation could also be a unique opportunity to turn a painful chapter in energy history into a positive force for the future.
Moreover, fusion power would help ensure that future energy crises are mitigated by providing a virtually inexhaustible source of energy without the environmental and geopolitical risks associated with fossil fuels. This shift aligns with the global movement toward decarbonization and could drive innovation in the energy sector.
In conclusion, turning Three Mile Island into a fusion power facility is not only a fitting way to honor the lessons learned from past nuclear accidents but also an opportunity to forge a new legacy—one based on safety, sustainability, and innovation.
FEEDBACK
samdhaklive-com-au- FEEDBACK
You encounter an island not being used for anything. This island is large and you could use it to produce more energy for your country. It can also be used as an area for more jobs for the community. This island that you encountered is the Three Mile Island in Pennsylvania which I believe must be used as a nuclear power plant for these reasons. It will provide more energy, and more jobs for the community.
Currently, the world’s islands are mainly used for shipping and tourism. When ships are travelling a long distance, they need to stop at these islands to refuel and have a break. Whereas, islands such as Fiji and Vanuatu have tourists from a variety of different countries come and visit them because of their features.
Firstly, it is crucial that Three Mile Island must be used as a nuclear power plant because it can provide more energy for America. 28% of all Americans live in a lower income household. Inputting a new energy plant could support these people in need of energy. If the amount of energy rises, the demand for it will decrease resulting in the prices descending. Another benefit of having a larger amount of energy is that they can sell the energy to other countries and use that money for general uses such as roads, and traffic lights. The money could even be donated to the people with a lower income.
Secondly, It is vitally important that Three mile island must be used as a nuclear power plant because it can provide more jobs for people. According to the Nuclear Energy Institute, 500 – 800 people work at every nuclear power plant, and there are 440 power plants in the whole world. That is between 220,000 and 532,000 people working in power plants across the world. That is how many people are earning money for their families. That is how many people are working to afford food and water. Money is needed to survive, without it, we are living in poverty. Imagine how many lives this job is saving?
To summarize, It is imperative that the Three Mile Island must be used for a nuclear power plant because it provides more energy for the country, and it provides more jobs for the citizens. Energy is one of our main ‘needs’ in our lives and without it, everything will be harder.
Kobe 🙂 🙂 🙂 :j
FEEDBACK
Shane Chee- FEEDBACK
Should the historic site of Three Mile Island, known for its infamous nuclear accident, be repurposed into a fusion power facility? Argue for or against this transformation, considering the legacy of nuclear power, the promise of fusion technology, and the lessons from past accidents. Use evidence from Rick’s perspective as both the grandson of a fission accident survivor and the son of a fusion pioneer to support your position.
Nuclear energy is a deadly yet revolutionary technological advancement. Today, I am standing before the legendary Three Mile Island Nuclear Plant. And in its glory, I witness a potential untapped. Three Mile Island, despite its severe nuclear accident, shouldn’t be repurposed and should retain its purpose as a Nuclear power plant. Despite its previous accidents, it has the potential to move us towards a greener future, a brighter society and a more stable economy. In this speech, I’ll be presenting 3 reasons why the legacy of Three Mile Island should undoubtedly be continued.
First and foremost, Nuclear energy is considered the most reliable power source in the modern era. With it’s near-zero greenhouse emissions and insurmountable energy output, it’s a highly efficient and versatile energy source. Not only that but nuclear energy can also help communities that don’t have much access to reliable energy. If we utilise nuclear energy at its finest, it can benefit the economy for the better helping us advance as a society.
Secondly, it requires low maintenance. As nuclear power plants become more and more independent and machines become more capable, the need for constant human supervision becomes less important. Nuclear power plants need minimal supervision and management, making outbreaks less eminent and making them more cost-effective regarding legal wages. If something bad occurs in nuclear power, as it did originally at Three Mile Island, it won’t affect as many people as it did in the ‘dawn’ of nuclear power where it needed constant workers and supervision.
On the other hand, one might say that nuclear power plants are extremely expensive and can cause severe casualties. Though this may be true, the expenses and casualties of nuclear power plants can be easily mitigated through the usage of long-term effects and robots – respectively. First of all, nuclear power plants may be really expensive to install, but can make quite a lot of profit – yes, not net revenue but instead profit. Cited by Brian Towne, a manager of a nuclear power plant, stated that after the construction fees are paid off, they make an average of about 5 million dollars per day. And that’s profit as well! Secondly, severe casualties caused by nuclear power plants are combated by the low number of workers at nuclear-energy-producing facilities. According to the World Nuclear Association, only two major nuclear disasters have occurred – and paired with modern technology, it turns danger rates to nearly 0%.
In conclusion, nuclear power plants have proven themselves to be quite safe—despite public unease—reliable and efficient sources of clean energy, and easy to manage with low maintenance. With their extreme energy output and incredible long-term profit, they prove themselves worthy as a pillar of our society and an energy of the future. And alongside them come many successors yet to come.
FEEDBACK
Benjamin Yang- FEEDBACK
Should Three Mile Island be transformed into a fusion power facility?
Three Mile Island is a site that many people cannect with the dangers of nuclear energy. In 1979, the plant had malfunction, which was a major accident in the history of nuclear power. However, looking at the site today, we have an opportunity to use it for something new and potentially much safer: fusion energy..
Cities should start using nuclear fusion power as it will stop green house gases from contaminating the atmosphere. If there are no greenhouse gases in the atmosphere, then it will help stop air polution which will pay back for the 1979 issue. This is evident because scientists have shown that air polution is way worse than the nuclear fusion power issue. Thus, nuclear gases will be a great help to our environment.
Additionally, Cities should start using nuclear fusion powers as it is extremley energy efficient. This is evident because it uses miniscule amount of fuel to generate the same amount of electricity that a coal or gas station would. At the same time, it doesn’t harm the environment. Therefore, this is very energy efficient and will help our environment.
moreover, Cities should start using nuclear fusion power as it very abundant in fuel. this is evident because deuterium can be extracted inexpensively from seawater, and tritium can potentially be produced from the reaction of fusion generated neutrons with naturally abundant lithium. This can also equal to a bigger value when it is just a small value. For example 1kg blocks equal to 1000 1gram blocks. You use 1 theing to represent so many things. If we use nuclear fusion then energy is very abundant in the world.
In conclusion, repurposing Three Mile Island for fusion energy makes sense. It would be a way to honor the lessons learned from past accidents, while also embracing the promise of a cleaner, safer future. Fusion power has the potential to change the world, and Three Mile Island could play a key role in that transformation.
FEEDBACK
sagar.khandre@gmail.com- FEEDBACK
Transforming 3 Mile Island into a Fusion Power Facility: The future of sustainable energy.
The 3 Mile Island, mainly known for its nuclear incident, presents a unique opportunity to lead the world in sustainable energy by transforming it into a fusion power facility. This change is not only feasible but also extremely important for several reasons.
Firstly, fusion power is the future of clean energy. Unlike classic nuclear fission, fusion power produces minimal radioactive waste and poses no risk of catastrophic meltdowns. By using the power of fusion, we can generate colossal amounts of energy with basically no impact on the environment. This tessellates perfectly with our war on climate change.
Secondly, the infrastructure on 3-mile island is already ideal for building a fusion facility so there would not be an extensive wait for the power plant to be built. Everything could be repurposed, hence leading to even more of a decreased carbon footprint and reduced costs. This makes the project economically viable and attractive to investors and governments alike.
Furthermore, transforming 3-mile island into a fusion facility would create hundreds of high-tech jobs and boost the local economy. It would make the island a leader in fusion technology and would put 3-mile island back on the map.
Lastly, this would go to show that we learn from past mistakes and it would make people around the world more secure on the topic of energy.
In conclusion, I strongly empower that 3-mile island should become a fusion power facility. It would help the world significantly in the big area of climate change and would provide a glimmer of hope for the world together with all the other sustainable energy sources.
Transforming 3 Mile Island into a Fusion Power Facility: The future of sustainable energy.
The 3 Mile Island, mainly known for its nuclear incident, presents a unique opportunity to lead the world in sustainable energy by transforming it into a fusion power facility. This change is not only feasible but also extremely important for several reasons.
Firstly, fusion power is the future of clean energy. Unlike classic nuclear fission, fusion power produces minimal radioactive waste and poses no risk of catastrophic meltdowns. By using the power of fusion, we can generate colossal amounts of energy with basically no impact on the environment. This tessellates perfectly with our war on climate change.
Secondly, the infrastructure on 3-mile island is already ideal for building a fusion facility so there would not be an extensive wait for the power plant to be built. Everything could be repurposed, hence leading to even more of a decreased carbon footprint and reduced costs. This makes the project economically viable and attractive to investors and governments alike.
Furthermore, transforming 3-mile island into a fusion facility would create hundreds of high-tech jobs and boost the local economy. It would make the island a leader in fusion technology and would put 3-mile island back on the map.
Lastly, this would go to show that we learn from past mistakes and it would make people around the world more secure on the topic of energy.
In conclusion, I strongly empower that 3-mile island should become a fusion power facility. It would help the world significantly in the big area of climate change and would provide a glimmer of hope for the world together with all the other sustainable energy sources.
Thank you for reading and I hope you enjoyed.
FEEDBACK
Chris Petzoldt- FEEDBACK
Thank you for marking 🙂
Topic: Should Three Mile Island be transformed into a fusion power facility?
Prompt: Should the historic site of Three Mile Island, known for its infamous nuclear accident, be repurposed into a fusion power facility? Argue for or against this transformation, considering the legacy of nuclear power, the promise of fusion technology, and the lessons from past accidents. Use evidence from Rick’s perspective as both the grandson of a fission accident survivor and the son of a fusion pioneer to support your position.
WRITING HOMEWORK/RESPONSE:
Envision yourself relaxing in the serenity of a casual Wednesday afternoon, when emergency klaxons fill the air. Blaring sirens pierced galvanic trepidation and anxiety into your brain, coursing through your veins in untrammeled jolts as you are forced to flee from your home. Insoluble, billowing white gas erupts from the nearby nuclear power-plants, pumping radioactive wisps into the firmament. The catastrophic nuclear accident still echoes through the minds of Three Mile Island’s locals, where the environment is still radioactive after almost 45 years, a testament to the consequences of nuclear fusion energy usage. This nuclear disaster is considered as the worst incident ever to occur in U.S. commercial nuclear power plant history. Diminishing nuclear fusion energy from our lives is imperative for addressing the major global issues that it causes.
Nuclear waste is a keystone in polluting the oceans. Nuclear fusion power plants produce radioactive waste when the neutrons produced by fusion activate the walls of the plasma vessel. As the nuclear industry grows, more and more nuclear waste is dumped into the oceans annually. The total amount of radioactive material dumped into the ocean is about 84,000 terabecquerels (TBq). The nuclear waste seeps into the waters, contaminating marine life via the food chain to even DNA damage. Nuclear waste can cause bioaccumulation in the marine food web when an infected species is consumed by a higher-rank organism, therefore also making them contaminated. Additionally, extensive exposure to radioactive waters can cause DNA damage for multiple species. A 2019 study found at least 18,000 radioactive objects scattered across the bottom of the Arctic Ocean, many of them dumped there by the Soviet Union. Between 1948 and 1982, the British government dumped approximately 70,000 tonnes of nuclear waste into the ocean. The US, Switzerland, Japan, and the Netherlands have also disposed of radioactive material in the ocean, but in smaller quantities. You might think that nuclear fusion energy can’t have a large impact on the cleanliness of the ocean since the radioactivity of nuclear waste decays over time, which is why waste is usually stored for about 50 years before actually being disposed of. However, even if the intensity of the radioactivity of atomic waste is decreased, it can still influence the atomic radiation of the ocean. Furthermore, it can amass over the years, threatening the countless marine species that roam the oceans. It is critical to remove nuclear fusion from our oceans to conserve the biodiversity of the seas.
Nuclear fusion power poses several potential health risks to humans. Similar to marine life, the ionising radiation from nuclear power-plants is lethal towards humans. Close contact to such conditions at high doses may immediately damage the body with radiation sickness to death. Even at lower doses, the radiation can cause health diseases like cardiovascular disease, cataracts, and cancer. Children and adolescents are especially sensitive towards the cancer effects of nuclear radioactivity. On the other hand, you may argue that some nuclear fusion power-plants are actually considered as safe, at least by the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) anyways. Supposedly, fusion power-plants are designed to protect workers, the public and other hazards from radiation. But what if there was a malfunction? Disasters can occur for any reason whatsoever, which can lead to calamitic events such as the Fukushima nuclear disaster. The Fukushima nuclear disaster was caused by the unexpected core damage of multiple nuclear power-plants. Without eliminating nuclear fusion energies, how else could we prevent unforeseen nuclear adversities in the future?
Radioactivity can also pollute the aerial environment. The grasps of radioactivity extend beyond just land and sea creatures. During the Three Mile Island Incident, a cooling malfunction caused part of Reactor 2’s core to melt, which therefore caused a ginormous amount of radioactive gases to be released into the environment, especially into the skies. According to Wikipedia, “Approximately 1,591 TBq (43,000 curies) of krypton were vented from the reactor building.” Radioactive gases in the atmosphere have multiple severe impacts on multiple aerial species. Substantial and prolonged exposure to radioactive environments can influence the pigmentation of almost all birds. The pigmentation of a bird often refers to a bird’s ability to resist the negative effects of radiation. Specifically, some birds with more pheomelanin in their feathers can experience poorer body condition, lower glutathione levels, higher oxidative stress to even DNA damage. These effects can be particularly dangerous and detrimental towards the status of their species. Some studies indicated that declines of bird species’ abundance and population density were correlated with the elevated levels of radiation found near Chernobyl. Birds play an imperative role in our local ecosystems. If the negative effects of radiation keep damaging the bird species that roam the global community, they may continue to diminish, unbalancing the natural euqilibrium. The atomic fumes of nuclear fusion power plants scattered across the world pose a critical threat to the world’s aerial species. We have the ability to protect our feathered friends through the diminishment of nuclear fusion energy.
Unrenewable and unsustainable energies such as nuclear fusion energy have built the framework for powering our modern industrialised world, fueling entire countries with its efficiency. But even such phenomena have a hidden darkside. From polluting the earth with its putrid and radioactive gases to endangering the innumerable living species that rule and roam the world, including us humans, nuclear fusion energy poses a major threat towards the community we have fabricated over the centuries. Rescue our planet from the lethal grasp of nuclear energies that hold unprecedented atrocities, and save our future generations from their unspoken horrors.
FEEDBACK
genwtfan- FEEDBACK
Prompt: Should the historic site of Three Mile Island, known for its infamous nuclear accident, be repurposed into a fusion power facility? Argue for or against this transformation, considering the legacy of nuclear power, the promise of fusion technology, and the lessons from past accidents. Use evidence from Rick’s perspective as both the grandson of a fission accident survivor and the son of a fusion pioneer to support your position. Narrative.
As Rick gazed out onto the colossal tower that stood before him, scarring the landscape that once used to be abundant of lush greenery. This place was an absolute mess, after what had occurred – the terrifying nuclear accident. He remembered exactly what had taken place – blood curdling screams and ear splitting explosions. But as he looked around him, Three Mile Island deserved a second chance.
Rick had intricately watched as his father devoted all his time into a rewarding success. The development of nuclear fusion would revolutionise the world. But when the accident happened, Rick’s father’s name went down with it, and many people were cautious and untrustworthy of him. But Rick didn’t want his father to remain disappointed, so he helped his father day after night, experimenting with wires, chemical reactions, and so much more.
Rick knew how much his father’s dream meant to him, and as his father became weary of age, he couldn’t let his dream crush. So, as days pass, Rick’s father eventually passes away. Even though of the loss, Rick slides the thought away and pursues his fathers dream. After years and years of dedication, it was finished.
Rick stood back from the creation. He knew that this would go down history, either way. As the machine began whirring, Rick’s mind whirled like a bull barging in his head. What if it didn’t work properly? What if I connected the wrong wires? What if nothing happens? Will my father be mad at me? Beads of sweat trickled down Rick’s temples. But his thoughts didn’t last for long. As the energy transferred through the tower, it illuminated the place. A crowd soon began forming around, clapping along with each other. They started cheering for Rick and his father. A smile crawled across Rick’s face, feeling his father’s smile glowing down on him, and his hands comfortingly placed down on his shoulder. He had done it.
FEEDBACK
Tina205- FEEDBACK
Scholarly Writing Wk 6
Prompt: Should the historic site of Three Mile Island, known for its infamous nuclear accident, be repurposed into a fusion power facility? Argue for or against this transformation, considering the legacy of nuclear power, the promise of fusion technology, and the lessons from past accidents. Use evidence from Rick’s perspective as both the grandson of a fission accident survivor and the son of a fusion pioneer to support your position.
Should Cities Switch to Nuclear Fusion Power?
Repurposing Three Mile Island into a fully functioning nuclear power plant is fraught with significant risks and concerns. Nuclear power, while potentially beneficial for our energy needs, has a history of catastrophic events and unresolved issues.
The most notable nuclear incidents—Three Mile Island, Chernobyl, and Fukushima—highlight the potential dangers. The Three Mile Island accident in 1979 caused widespread fear and revealed significant vulnerabilities in nuclear safety protocols. While the immediate health impacts were limited, the socio-economic consequences and loss of public trust in nuclear energy were profound.
The Chernobyl disaster in 1986 was even more devastating. The explosion and fire at the reactor released large amounts of radioactive materials into the environment, resulting in severe health effects for those exposed. The creation of a vast exclusion zone that remains uninhabitable today illustrates the long-term consequences of nuclear accidents.
The Fukushima disaster in 2011 underscored the unpredictability of nuclear power in the face of natural disasters. Although there were no immediate deaths from radiation exposure, radionuclides such as iodine-131, caesium-134, and caesium-137 entered the ocean, drinking water, and food supplies. The long-lasting contamination highlights the severe risks of nuclear energy.
Moreover, the management of nuclear waste remains an unsolved problem. Nuclear reactors produce radioactive waste that remains hazardous for hundreds to thousands of years. This waste must be carefully managed to prevent environmental contamination. Currently, no fully effective and universally accepted methods for long-term disposal exist. Some countries, like Japan, have resorted to dumping radioactive waste into the ocean, a practice that poses significant environmental risks and has been met with international criticism.
The arguments in favor of nuclear power often cite its low greenhouse gas emissions compared to fossil fuels. Proponents argue that with proper safety measures and advancements in technology, nuclear energy can be a clean and reliable energy source. However, the history of nuclear energy reveals that even with stringent safety protocols, accidents can and do happen, leading to catastrophic consequences.
The potential for human error, natural disasters, and technical failures means that the risks associated with nuclear energy cannot be entirely eliminated. The accumulation of nuclear waste, which is difficult and dangerous to manage, further complicates the picture. This waste poses long-term environmental and health risks, as it can contaminate water supplies and ecosystems if not properly contained.
Nuclear power also has significant economic costs. Building and maintaining nuclear power plants requires substantial investment, and the costs associated with cleanup and decommissioning after an accident are enormous. The financial burden, combined with the potential for environmental and health impacts, makes nuclear power a less attractive option compared to renewable energy sources.
Ultimately, while nuclear power has the potential to provide a substantial portion of our energy needs with minimal greenhouse gas emissions, the risks and challenges associated with it are considerable. The history of nuclear accidents, the unresolved issue of nuclear waste disposal, and the potential for catastrophic environmental and health impacts suggest that repurposing Three Mile Island—or any site with a troubled nuclear history—into a functioning nuclear power plant is not a prudent choice. Instead, investing in safer and more sustainable energy sources, such as wind, solar, and hydroelectric power, would better address our energy needs and environmental concerns.
FEEDBACK
Phuong Nguyen- FEEDBACK
Given the fact that Three Mile Island sits at an historic site, one must consider, in general, a number of factors involving the legacy of nuclear power, the promise of fusion technology, and lessons learned from past accidents when considering the potential repurposing as a fusion power facility. I, Rick-the grandson of a survivor of the fission accident at Three Mile Island and the son of a fusion pioneer-strongly support this transformation.
First, the legacy of nuclear power is chequered with both achievements and tragedies. The incident at Three Mile Island in 1979 serves as a grim reminder of the risks involved with fission-based nuclear energy, showing potential dangers when technology fails or human error occurs. On the other hand, it drove an important evolution in safety protocols and regulatory measures that have since enhanced the industry. It is important to realize that the study of history, though replete with cautionary tales, also teaches inestimable lessons. Repurposing the site for fusion power can be interpreted as a turn away from the dangerous legacy of fission and as part of an innovative spirit which could rejuvenate a community tied up in painful history.
Fusion technology, often considered the “holy grail” in energy production, has many advantages over traditional nuclear fission. Fusion reactions – processes similar to those that power the sun – generate energy by combining light atomic nuclei and produce minimal long-lived radioactive waste. What’s more, the possibility of a catastrophic failure akin to fission power plants, such as at Chernobyl or Fukushima, is practically nil for fusion plants, as the process requires extreme conditions to sustain and will naturally shut off if those conditions are not met. This will involve harnessing the promise of a safe, clean, and virtually limitless energy source by transforming the Three Mile Island site into a fusion facility and further working on active remedies against the fears brought about by its fission counterpart.
Born the son of a fusion pioneer, I have been privileged in having first-hand experience with the potential this technology holds. It has allowed me a peek into the dedication and ingenuity driving research and innovation in this field, and I believe it can also serve as an antidote not only to our energy crisis but also to historical anxieties surrounding nuclear energy. A fusion facility at Three Mile Island will stand for redemption and hope-a stark message that humankind can learn from its mistakes and take a different route toward sustainability.
This would not only be transformational in an economic and social sense but would also provide considerable benefits. Such a facility would provide jobs, offer investment opportunities, and accommodate research and development activities that enhance local economies. In this way, it can be a source of revitalization to honour the victims of the accident and a modern path of innovation for future generations.
We may be able to repurpose a Three Mile Island facility for fusion power, thus reminiscing about the past and moving into a progressive future. It characterizes our capability of learning from history, our commitment to the tradition of safety and innovation, and our yearning to adopt renewable energy solutions that will carry us into a new energy frontier. Let us seize this chance to transform a site of tragedy into a beacon of hope and progress.
FEEDBACK
dineshaggarwal13yahoo-com- FEEDBACK
Oops sent the wrong one
Critical Headline Times 12
FEEDBACK
Nathaniel Abustan – WK6 FEEDBACK